Treasure Island vs. St. Pete Beach: Which Florida Gulf Coast Destination is Right for You?

Sunset Beach, Treasure Island — wide, uncrowded, and one of Florida's best-kept secrets. (Taken right across the street from Funshine Sunset Beach.)

Planning a Gulf Coast Florida vacation and can't decide between Treasure Island and St. Pete Beach? You're not alone — it's one of the most common questions we hear from guests. Both are gorgeous, sun-soaked barrier islands on Tampa Bay's doorstep, but they have distinct personalities. Here's your honest, locals-perspective guide to help you choose.